Good news in our gospel today, eh? Actually, it is, if we have ears to hear.
Last week, I mentioned that we often hear biblical stories the way the church that raised us taught us to hear them. Our lectionary today offers us a few concepts we were raised to find familiar, and we will reflect on them from a Biblically grounded perspective.
Our Collect reflects an early Christian belief that we are unworthy and dare not ask God for mercy. This sense of unworthiness derives from Augustine of Hippo’s 3rd century doctrine of original sin - that we are born in a state of sin. This doctrine was later strengthened and expanded by John Calvin and other Reformers in the 15th century, and sadly, it survives and thrives in much of Christianity today. I say sadly, because it is not a biblical teaching.
As Episcopalians, you may cling to this teaching if you choose to, but we engage with the biblical teaching that we are born in the image and likeness of God (Gen 1:27). The world may challenge and tempt us away from that, but God stands steadfastly with us, reminding us of the truth of who we are and whose we are, continually guiding us back to our created state of original goodness - which is how redemption works.
Jesus directly addresses the issue of worthiness in the parable of the wheat and weeds. In Jesus’ time, you could sabotage a harvest of wheat by throwing in the seeds of bearded darnell, a weed-grain that looks a lot like wheat but is bitter and toxic in its maturity. The roots of this weed eventually wind together with the roots of the wheat. Once that happens, it is impossible to remove until the threshing.
Experienced field hands knew that the logical thing to do would be to pull out the weeds quickly so they don’t steal soil space and nutrients from the grain. But Jesus’ parable, like all parables, surprises. The farmer instructs them to let the wheat and the weeds grow together. At harvest time, they will be separated by the reapers, not the field hands, and dealt with according to the will of the farmer. This is Jesus clarifying that the separation of the weeds from the wheat is a divine task, not a human one.
Much of the commentary and discussion about this parable talk about the judgment of God being terrible - the bad weeds (people) being thrown into fire with weeping and gnashing of teeth, and they warn us that God’s justice for us is like that. In his life and ministry, however, Jesus demonstrated a loving, forgiving, humble character. When the law would have allowed Jesus to punish sin, he didn’t. Instead, he forgave people their sins and clarified that the law was meant to serve and benefit humans, not the other way around. (Mk 2:27)
God’s commitment is to reconcile all people, even those who are evil, which, btw, doesn’t mean bad. Evil persons are those who, by their intention or actions, cause division, harm, or sadness; those who build systems that make the burdens of others heavy or oppressive. They may do bad things, but they are not bad.
Jesus demonstrated this reconciling nature of God by calling Matthew, a tax collector, the very definition of an evil person, to be a disciple, transforming him into an apostle, and what a beautiful, hopeful demonstration that is! As for us, we acknowledge in our Catechism that it is also our mission to “restore all people, the wheat and the weeds, “to unity with God and each other in Christ." (Book of Common Prayer, p 855)
In this parable, Jesus is instructing us to live together, being cautious of our judgment. We tend to judge the wheat as good and the weeds as bad, but we need to be careful, because we’re often wrong.
From my grandmother, who was an herbalist, I learned that dandelions are highly nutritious: the flowers, the leaves, and the roots. They are also the first food of pollinators every Spring. It has always shocked me that people will go to such great lengths to eliminate this nutritious plant from their yards, even resorting to known cancer-causing chemicals to destroy them, prioritizing instead manicured grass, which, though pretty, offers nothing of value to humans or pollinators.
Historically, we have also labeled whole groups of people as bad weeds, haven’t we? Currently, LGBTQIA2S+ people, immigrants, women, people of color, and the poor are at the top of our lists.
Jesus teaches us that the weeds will be separated from the wheat by divine action, not ours. When the weeds are separated out, they will be reborn in God because that is the love and mercy of God: to retrieve all that is lost, broken, or damaged and redeem it – bringing new life from death.
We must remember that the weeds are also created by God, and the people deemed to be weeds are also the dwelling places of the presence of God. They may be lost, to be sure, but we know how Jesus felt about leaving the many to go after even one who is lost. So, Jesus says, the wheat and the weeds must live together, entwined by the roots of our common humanity, because God seeks to redeem and reconcile all.
That doesn’t always happen in our lifetimes, as we well know. Sometimes the weeds die in their evil state, unrepentant and still doing harm. Establishing boundaries that protect us from their evil answers Jesus’ call to honor and respect ourselves. As I often say, we may have to let Jesus accomplish the redemption in the next life, when our efforts have failed, which is one reason why praying for the dead matters.
Jesus says, when the angels of God separate the wheat from the weeds, the weeds will be thrown into the furnace of fire where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. This powerful portion of Jesus’ teaching pierces the very heart of the apocalyptic tradition in Judaism, a tradition that was carried into Christianity as fire and brimstone threats - but that misunderstands the tradition.
First, let’s consider how fire is used in the Bible. There’s the famously burning bush through which God spoke to Moses (Ex 3:1), and the “appearance of the glory of God was like a devouring fire on the top of the mountain for all the people to see.” (Ex 24: 17) In Luke 3:16, John the Baptist declared that the Messiah would baptize with the Holy Spirit and fire.
Fire is biblical language for the presence of God. When the weeds are thrown into the fire, they are thrown into the presence of God where, of course, there would be weeping and gnashing of teeth because those who believe in their own power will resist dying to self, but in the presence of God, who is love, the revelation of the harm they have done will leave them full of remorse as their systems of denial and justification fail, and they know the fullness of their guilt.
This is why we continually repent - which simply means change our course, change what we’re doing, thinking, or believing - and return to God as our Baptismal vows call us to do. Mercifully, God responds by doing what God always does – forgiving us, loving us, and redirecting us, giving us another chance to live the lives of love we were created to live.
When we are in the presence of God, no matter how unworthy we might have been taught to feel, the pervasiveness of God’s love saturates us, and we can only - finally - love back. It is the ultimate healing. It is reconciliation.
Then, as the parable says, those who have been reconciled back into right relationship in the fire of the divine presence will shine like the sun in the kingdom of God. God’s plan of redemptive, reconciling love for the whole world is reassuring, encouraging, healing, and loving, not threatening.
What if we approach our loving, merciful God, and ask God to heal our brokenness – brokenness we know we have, and brokenness we don’t yet know we have. What if we actually trusted God’s plan of salvation to make us and everyone whole? What if we lived as Jesus showed us how to live, in the midst of yet another harsh and destructive historical moment?
We can do this only through the power of the love of God in Christ who dwells in us, guiding our every step.
I close with a prayer I adapted from our Noonday Prayer service (BCP, 107).
Let us pray. Redeeming God, you have sent your Holy Spirit into our hearts, to direct and serve us according to your will, to comfort us in all our afflictions, to defend us from error, and to lead us into all truth. We thank you and bless you for steadfastly loving and caring for us in the name of Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.




























