Peace be with you. (The people respond: And also with you.) Por favor, tomen asiento. Please be seated.
I always enjoy the Pentecost tradition of speaking the gospel in many languages all at once. It enables us to experience the limits of our ability to manage sensory input, to hear and understand in the midst of cacophony. At the same time, it offers us the opportunity to marvel at the gift of our diversity.
I've always wished I could be one of those people who could speak multiple languages. Alas, I never had time or opportunity in my life to pursue that dream, but God led me toward another dream I hadn’t even had yet: learning the language of Spirit. Discerning the voice of God, and teaching others how to do that, is the foundation of my ministry.
Discernment is a spiritual gift, and it takes practice. It also takes a community. In the Episcopal Church, discernment is always practiced individually AND in community in a dynamic trinitarian dance of myself, God, and my community. If God is left out of the dance, the path becomes dark and destructive.
Many of us remember, with lingering incredulity, the 1978 Jonestown Massacre, the tragic event where the phrase, “drinking the Kool-Aid” was born. It’s hard to believe that so many people could be led to blindly follow a bizarre ideology proffered by an obviously deranged man and cling to the hope of his promised reward held up like a carrot.
Sadly, it happens a lot. Nazi Germany under Hitler, for another example. Shadows of this are becoming more and more apparent in our world today, which is why practicing and teaching the gift of discernment matters.
In our Collect, we asked God to give us right judgment in all things. Judgment is both discernment and decision. Our discernment is that we see and understand as God would have us do amid the cacophony around us so that we can decide faithfully, responding to the voice of God rather than the voice of the world.
When you hear the word judgment, is that what you hear? Or do you hear the church-driven cultural meaning? If you look up the word judgment in the dictionary, the 2nd definition is: a misfortune or calamity viewed as divine punishment.
This is shockingly sad, and we must repent of that as Church. Why? Because it’s unfaithful, unscriptural, and uncharacteristic of the God of love. God’s judgment always was and still is salvation, rescue, reclamation of all by the forgiveness of sin, which is anything that divides us or disrupts our loving relationships with God, one another, and ourselves. This divine judgment was demonstrated and inaugurated in the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus, the Christ.
Our habit of making judgment into a fear of divine punishment perverts a word that should offer us the ultimate comfort! Why have we done this to ourselves? It’s heart-breaking to me. On this wonderful day of Pentecost, when the Spirit of God enters us in a real, sensory, and spiritual way, let’s commit to repent of that habit.
The gospel from John reflects divine preparation for the event later described in the Book of Acts – an event that left everyone amazed and perplexed. John tells of Jesus’ post-resurrection appearance to his close-knit community hiding in fear in a locked room.
Unhindered by the earthly barrier of locked doors, Jesus stands among them. Amazed and perplexed barely covers how they must have felt. Jesus says, “Peace be with you” and shows them his wounds, so they’ll know it’s really him.
The followers rejoiced when they recognized him, so Jesus says again, “Peace be with you” to calm them. Then, breathing his own Sprit, the Spirit of the Triune God, into them, Jesus says, as God has sent me, I now send you.
Breathing is a powerful and symbolic word that harkens back to the creation story in Genesis where Creator God breathed life into humans. Now God in Christ, is breathing a new life, a spiritual life into humans – for a purpose!
At our Bible study, one of our members asked, “Is the Spirit of God really in me?” The answer is a resounding YES! It is! Our whole goal, especially on this Pentecost Sunday, is to awaken to the truth of that and ponder what It means for us.
Then comes the strongest admonition I’ve ever heard Jesus give: “if you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them. If you retain the sins of any they are retained.” Despite what you may have heard this is NOT Jesus giving authority to humans to forgive or not forgive the sinful acts of others. That remains the realm and authority of God alone.
It IS Jesus warning these disciples (and us) that since the reconciliation of the whole world to God by the forgiveness of sin has been inaugurated by Jesus’s death and resurrection, there is something important for them (and us) to remember as we are sent into the world to continue this work. Here it is: when we forgive as radically as Jesus did from the cross, all who are held in the bondage of sin are set free. When we do not forgive, we perpetuate the power and destructiveness of that sin in the world. We must, therefore, be careful and faithful in how we choose to respond.
Last week, I was at the Asian American, Native Hawaiian, Pacific Islander (AANHPI) celebration where the bishop of Idaho, Jos Tharakan, gave a personal testimony about being the parent of a daughter, and how he might respond if a man came into his confessional and said he’d sexually assaulted that daughter. Bp. Jos said that he’d offer him absolution since he confessed, then he’d leave the confessional, go to the man, and shoot him.
Shocking, right? But also relatable. Bp. Jos clarified that he wouldn’t ever really do that, but he’d want to! Then he reminded us of the difference between reacting and responding.
He’s right, and while Bp. Jos didn’t elaborate that night, I will now, especially as we approach our gun violence prevention efforts.
Reactions are reflexive. Often motivated by fear or anger, even righteous anger, a reaction like the one Bp. Jos described is totally human, but we must practice restraint so that a thoughtful, faithful response can be formed in us. This is why Jesus repeated, “Peace be with you” to the disciples.
In the midst of a cacophonous, excited, emotional state, we must pause to discern how to see and understand what’s happening as God would have us do, and hear God’s guidance for how we are to respond. Shooting another child of God is never the answer, as justified and effective as it may seem, but a faithful response only comes to us when we pause, enter that dynamic trinitarian discernment dance, and listen.
Bp. Jos offered one more bit of wisdom I’ll share with you today because it speaks to the letter to the Corinthians which reminds us that we are all one. Bp. Jos said that as a bishop in the church, he has the authority to tell his flock who they can hate, so he gives them permission to hate any person who is not created by God.
On that first Pentecost, the disciples were speaking to people from many nations, races, and languages, people who practiced religion, and people who didn’t, men and women, slaves and free people. God didn’t ask them to speak only to those worthy to hear, or qualified to hear, or even to those ready to hear.
God's guidance was: speak to the people I have brought near to you and watch me act through your faithfulness. So, they did… and all who were gathered could hear and understand the good news being spoken to them. No one could explain how it happened, only that it did happen.
Our dismissal every Sunday sends us into the world as it is today, to continue the work of reconciliation by the forgiveness of sin, begun by Jesus. We will confront some things those first disciples encountered, like the horrible treatment of immigrants. We will also confront things they never imagined, like the cruel treatment of LGBTQIA2S+ people.
![]() |
| Image by Hildgard of Bingen: God, Cosmos, and Humanity, 1150 AD |
Peace be with you. (The people respond: And also with you.) And there we have the perfect example of a reflexive spiritual response born of practice in community. Amen.



























